Anhui Dainamu Heavy Industry Technology Co., Ltd.

HomeNewsBest Equipment for Primary Crushing: Jaw vs. Gyratory Crushers

Best Equipment for Primary Crushing: Jaw vs. Gyratory Crushers

Release Time: 2025-03-21

share:

Crushing is a cornerstone of material processing, pivotal in industries such as mining, construction, and recycling. At Dainamu, based in China, we provide cutting-edge crushing solutions designed to optimize efficiency and durability. This content delves into the process of selecting equipment for the first stage of crushing, offering detailed insights into crusher types, selection criteria, technical specifications, and environmental considerations.

Table of Contents

1. Introduction to Crushing Processes

Crushing involves breaking down large pieces of solid materials—such as ore, coal, or rock—into smaller sizes, typically exceeding 5 mm, to achieve a specific granulometric composition or to liberate minerals for further processing. This process leverages external forces like compression, tension, bending, or shear, which target weaknesses in the material’s structure, such as defects, layering, porosity, or cracks. At Dainamu in China, we recognize that the success of crushing operations hinges on understanding material properties like strength (hardness) and crushability.

The energy required for crushing can be assessed using several established theories:

  • Kirpichev’s Hypothesis: Suggests that the work of crushing is proportional to the increase in surface area or the square of the material’s diameter, ideal for coarse crushing.
  • Rittinger’s Hypothesis: Posits that energy is proportional to the new surface area created, best suited for fine crushing or grinding.
  • Bond’s Law: Links energy to changes in both volume and surface area, offering accuracy for medium crushing.

These theories enable precise calculations of crusher performance parameters, including energy consumption, motor power, throughput, and maximum crushing forces. Dainamu leverages such principles to design equipment like our mobile jaw crusher for hard rock, ensuring optimal performance across various applications.

2. Methods and Principles of Crushing

Crushing employs multiple methods, each suited to specific material types and operational goals:

  • Compression: Used for hard materials, exceeding the material’s compressive strength limit, common in jaw and gyratory crushers.
  • Splitting: Involves tension-induced cleavage, effective for brittle or viscous materials like coal or limestone.
  • Bending: Breaks material through flexure, often seen in softer rocks.
  • Shear: Cuts material via sliding forces, less common but useful in specific contexts.
  • Impact: Combines compression, tension, and shear, ideal for brittle substances.
  • Abrasion: Minor grinding action due to shear, typically a secondary effect.

Compression dominates modern crushing due to its efficiency and equipment design practicality, despite materials being weaker under tension. Crushing can be mechanical (most common), pneumatic (explosive), electrohydraulic, electro-impulse, electrothermal, or aerodynamic, categorized as static (e.g., compression in jaw crushers) or dynamic (e.g., impact in rotor crushers). At Dainamu, our mobile crushing and screening plants integrate these methods for versatile applications in China and beyond.

Crushing stages vary by output size: coarse (100-350 mm), medium (40-100 mm), and fine (5-40 mm). Purposes include preparatory (for beneficiation), final (for marketable products like coal grades), or selective (targeting weaker components). Processes often pair with pre-screening, directing only oversized material to crushers, and operate in open or closed cycles—closed cycles enhance product uniformity and reduce energy use.

3. Types of Crushing Equipment for the First Stage

The first stage of crushing, or primary crushing, reduces large feed sizes to a manageable range (100-350 mm). Equipment selection depends on material properties and operational demands. Below are the primary options:

3.1 Jaw Crushers

Jaw crushers excel in primary crushing, handling large, hard, and abrasive materials via compression between a fixed and moving jaw. Dainamu’s mobile jaw crusher is renowned in China for its robustness and adaptability.

  • Advantages: High durability, adjustable output size, suitability for tough materials like granite.
  • Applications: Mining, quarrying, and recycling.

3.2 Gyratory Crushers

Gyratory crushers feature a conical head gyrating within a concave bowl, offering continuous crushing for high-capacity operations. They handle large feed sizes efficiently, ideal for large-scale mining.

  • Advantages: High throughput, uniform output, reduced wear costs.
  • Applications: Ore processing, aggregate production.

3.3 Other Crusher Options

Roll crushers (for softer materials) and impact crushers (for brittle rocks) are less common in primary crushing but viable in niche scenarios. Jaw and gyratory crushers, however, dominate due to their strength and versatility.

4. Criteria for Selecting Crushing Equipment

Choosing the right crusher involves assessing multiple factors:

  • Material Hardness: Hard materials (e.g., granite) require jaw or gyratory crushers.
  • Feed Size: Maximum input size (e.g., 800 mm) dictates crusher opening size.
  • Output Size: Desired range (e.g., 100-350 mm) influences crusher settings.
  • Capacity: Hourly throughput needs align with crusher size and power.
  • Cost Efficiency: Balances initial investment, maintenance, and energy use.

Dainamu’s experts in China assist clients in aligning these factors with operational goals, ensuring selections like our mobile jaw crushers meet specific needs.

5. Technical Selection of First-Stage Crushers

For a material with a compressive strength of 50 MPa and a maximum feed size of 800 mm, we evaluate suitable crushers:

Crusher Type Max Feed Size (mm) Discharge Gap (mm) Adjustment Range (mm) Capacity (m³/s) Motor Power (kW)
Mobile Crushing PlantSE-1060 (Jaw)
800 110 ±40 0.0685 160
Mobile Gyratory PlantSE-150 (Gyratory)
1000 150 ±22 0.161 250
Mobile Roll PlantSE 216
600 130-200 - 0.195 200

The ЩДС-12x15 jaw crusher is selected for its balance of capacity (0.0685 m³/s), power efficiency (160 kW), and ability to handle the 800 mm feed size with a 110 mm discharge gap, yielding a maximum output size of approximately 165 mm.

6. Case Studies and Practical Applications

Case Study 1: Granite Processing in China

A mining operation processing granite (50 MPa, 800 mm feed) adopted Dainamu’s ЩДС-12x15 jaw crusher. With a 110 mm gap, it achieved a throughput of 25.79 kg/s, meeting output requirements of 100-350 mm efficiently.

Case Study 2: Limestone Quarrying

A quarry in China processing limestone (1000 mm feed) opted for a gyratory crusher (ККД-1000/150), leveraging its 0.161 m³/s capacity for high-volume production, reducing downstream processing needs.

7. Environmental Protection in Crushing Operations

Dainamu prioritizes sustainability in China:

  • Air Quality: Dust suppression systems and compliance with emission standards.
  • Water Management: Treatment and recycling of process water.
  • Waste: Repurposing by-products to minimize landfill use.

8. Safety Measures for Crushing Operations

Safety is paramount:

  • Protective Gear: Helmets, respirators, and noise protection.
  • Training: Regular sessions on equipment handling.
  • Maintenance: Routine checks to prevent hazards.

10. Conclusion

Selecting first-stage crushing equipment requires balancing material properties, technical specs, and economic factors. Dainamu’s solutions in China ensure efficiency and sustainability.

11. Contact Dainamu

For tailored advice, reach us at anhuisiluoman@gmail.com or visit dainamu.com.

Dainamu

High Precision from Dainamu!

Provide your needs

Request a Quote

If you have any questions
please feel free to contact us.